Quick answer: A water heater that keeps cycling with no hot water in use is usually either losing heat (a recirculation system or failing part) or losing water (a leak). If closing the heater's cold-water inlet stops your water meter, the hot side is leaking, and a hot-water slab leak is the most common culprit.

Losing heat or losing water?

A tank heater reheats when its water cools or when cold water flows in to replace hot water that left. So constant running has two families of causes:

  • Losing heat: a hot-water recirculation pump running around the clock, a faulty thermostat or heating element, heavy sediment, or a tank in a cold space.
  • Losing water: a dripping hot faucet, a leaking temperature and pressure (T&P) relief valve, a leaking tank, or a leak in a hot-water line, often under the slab.

Check the easy things first

  1. Look at the T&P valve discharge pipe on the side of the heater. If it drips or is wet, the valve may be leaking or the pressure may be too high.
  2. Look around the base of the tank for water or rust.
  3. Check hot taps and shower heads for drips.
  4. Recirculation pump: if you have one, check whether its timer is set to run 24 hours a day.

The test that points to a slab leak

  1. Turn off all water use in the house and the irrigation controller.
  2. Note your water meter's leak indicator.
  3. Close the cold-water inlet valve on top of the water heater.
  4. Watch the meter for 15 minutes.

If the meter stopped when you closed the inlet, water was flowing into the hot side to replace a leak. If the tank, the T&P valve, and the hot faucets are dry, the leak is hidden in a hot-water line, very often under the slab. Walk the floors barefoot: a warm spot usually marks the area.

Leave the inlet closed until repairs if you can manage without hot water. It stops the leak and the energy waste.

Why hot-water lines fail first

Hot water speeds up corrosion inside copper, and hot lines expand and contract every time they are used. In Rancho Palos Verdes homes built in the 1950s to the 1970s, the hot-water branches under the slab are typically the first to develop pinhole leaks. Recirculation systems, which keep hot water moving constantly, can add to that wear.

How it gets fixed

A technician confirms the leak with a pressure test on the hot side and pinpoints it with thermal imaging and acoustic equipment. See slab leak detection. The repair is either a spot repair through the floor or a reroute of the hot-water lines. Because hot lines tend to fail one after another, many homeowners reroute all the hot-water branches at once.

For prices, see the slab leak repair cost guide.

People Also Ask

Common questions

Why does my water heater keep running when no one is using hot water?

Either it is losing heat, from a recirculation pump or a faulty part, or it is losing water through a leak. A meter test with the heater's inlet closed tells you which.

Can a slab leak make my water heater run all the time?

Yes. A leak in a hot-water line under the slab keeps drawing hot water out, so cold water flows in and the heater keeps reheating.

Is it safe to turn off my water heater's water supply?

Yes. Closing the cold-water inlet stops water entering the tank. For a gas heater, set it to pilot or vacation; for electric, switch off the breaker if the tank might drain.

Does a recirculation pump cause slab leaks?

It does not cause them, but constant circulation keeps hot water moving through the lines, which can speed up wear on older copper.

Should I replace my water heater?

Not because of a slab leak. The heater is usually fine. Fix the leaking line, then check whether the heater still cycles normally.